Sometimes, but only under the rules that govern your records, and never as a general permission. The state archives we checked allow government offices to destroy paper after scanning when the records are not permanent, the scans meet the state’s imaging rules, quality has been checked and the retention schedule allows it. Permanent and archival records face extra conditions, such as an appraisal, a microfilm or paper duplicate, or stricter storage rules, and some originals are worth keeping whatever the law permits.
This article is not legal advice. It summarizes what five state archives and the federal rules said when we checked them in November 2026, and it is written for county and city clerks, district records managers and the archivists who advise them. Before you destroy anything, confirm the current rules with your state archives, your retention schedule and your counsel.
The short answer, and the two questions inside it
“Can we destroy the paper?” is really two questions. The first is legal: does the law and your retention schedule allow a scanned copy to replace the original? The second is a preservation judgment: even if it is allowed, is this original worth keeping?
Legal permission
Every state answer below starts from the same idea. A digital copy can serve as the official record if it is complete, accurate and accessible for as long as the record must be kept. The conditions differ from state to state: who must approve the destruction, how the images must be made and checked, and what happens to permanent or archival records.
Preservation judgment
Even where the law says yes, some originals carry value a scan cannot hold: signatures and seals, bindings and paper that date a document, records whose authenticity might one day be questioned, and records people will want to see in person. The Texas State Library and Archives Commission puts it plainly in its FAQ on scanning and destruction: “Some records may (or should) be kept in the original physical format based on historical, financial or legal value.”
Four questions, in order
The figure puts the two questions into a sequence an office can follow for each series. Each “no” stops the path to destruction; only a series that passes all four ends at the shredder, and even then under the schedule, with a record of what was done.
Who these rules apply to
Records retention laws are written for government bodies: state agencies, counties, municipalities, school and special districts. A historical society or museum holding donated papers generally answers to its deeds of gift and collections policy rather than to a public records schedule, and scanning is rarely a reason to discard archival originals there. This article is about public records.
Decide whether scanning is worth it before asking about destruction
The cheapest way to get rid of paper is to destroy what has already met its retention, under the schedule, before anyone scans it. Scanning is worth its cost for records that must be kept a long time and that people use; it is rarely worth it for records that will soon be eligible for destruction anyway.
Clear out eligible records first
The Oregon State Archives’ guidance starts here: “It’s important to perform review and destruction of eligible records before starting any scanning project to avoid unnecessary costs.” Records that have met their scheduled retention, with no legal hold, should be destroyed under the approved schedule, not scanned and then destroyed.
Prioritize by retention and use
Oregon suggests that records with a permanent retention “can be a great place to begin because those records will get maximum value from being made more accessible over time,” and that for records with retention of “10 years or less,” agencies should ask whether digitizing is worth the effort. It also points to frequently requested records, because digital copies can be used by several people at once and make public records requests easier to answer.
Texas makes the same point with examples from a conversation with a county clerk. Naturalization records “would be a good start because they have high value to citizens”; land records got “a strong maybe”; attorneys’ receipt books rated “pretty low priority.” The FAQ adds that “you don’t have to scan everything” and that “it’s not cost-efficient or best practice to just scan everything and keep only electronic copies.”
Start with one series
Oregon recommends choosing “one cohesive record series” as a pilot, such as meeting minutes, contracts or annual budget reports, to gauge the workload, set up workflows and naming, and test storage before scaling up. A pilot also tells you, with your own numbers, whether the scans will be good enough to replace paper for that series.
How five states and the federal government answer
The answers conflict in their details, which is why one state’s FAQ cannot settle the question in another. The table summarizes what each source said when we read it; the sections below give the conditions in each source’s own words.
| Jurisdiction | Short answer | Main conditions | Permanent or archival records |
|---|---|---|---|
| Colorado (State Archives FAQ; C.R.S. 24-71.3-112) | Yes, under the Uniform Electronic Transactions Act | Copy accurately reflects the record and remains accessible; a scanning policy recommended | Consider keeping paper for records with retention of ten years or longer |
| Texas (TSLAC FAQ, 2020) | Yes for state agencies and local governments | Electronic records rules; for local records kept 10 years or more, standards including visual checks of at least 10% of documents | Extra requirements for archival, permanent and vital records |
| Washington (advice sheet, May 2024) | Yes, if the agency follows the steps | Scan to the state's requirements; verify the conversion | "Archival" records need a State Archives appraisal first |
| North Carolina (State Archives) | Yes for non-permanent records, with approval | Signed Electronic Records and Imaging Policy; local governments file a destruction request | Preservation duplicate on paper or microfilm required |
| Oregon (Digitization Guidance, February 2026) | Yes once scans are reviewed for quality and completeness | OAR 166-017 scanning and storage rules | Retention of 100 years or more: digital-only storage only if it meets the State Archives' requirements |
| Federal agencies (36 CFR 1236; GRS 4.5) | Yes after validation, under a schedule or GRS 4.5 | Image quality standards, QC sampling, validation by separate staff | GRS 4.5 excludes pre-1950 permanent records and records with intrinsic value |
Colorado
The Colorado State Archives’ records management FAQ answers the question directly: “Can our office scan and destroy our paper records? The answer is yes.” It explains that the Uniform Electronic Transactions Act “provides the framework for scanned documents to be accepted as the legal copy,” and then adds a caution: “For records with a retention period of ten years or longer a district may want to consider keeping the paper records after scanning and using the scans for reference.”
The statute behind that answer is C.R.S. 24-71.3-112. It says a legal requirement to retain a record is met by an electronic record that “accurately reflects the information set forth in the record after it was first generated in its final form” and “remains accessible for later reference.” Subsection 4 extends this to laws requiring a record “in its original form,” and subsection 7 keeps the door open for more: the section “does not preclude a governmental agency of this state from specifying additional requirements.” A separate section, 24-71.3-117, gives counties, municipalities and other political subdivisions the general power “to determine the extent to which it will create and retain electronic records.”
Retention itself comes from schedules. The State Archives prepares retention and disposition schedules for state agencies, counties, municipalities, school districts and special districts, and they advise officials which records must be kept permanently. Counties and municipalities apply to use them.
For a Colorado office, that means three things to settle before scanning: which of the series are permanent on your approved schedule, whether any state agency that oversees a series has added its own requirements, and whether the scanned records will meet the statute’s two tests for the full retention period. The State Archives answers questions by phone and email and offers one-on-one consultations, according to the same FAQ.
Texas
The Texas State Library and Archives Commission describes this as perhaps the most frequent question it gets. Its 2020 FAQ says records laws for state agencies and local governments “do allow for records to be kept electronically in addition to, or instead of, physical copies.” For local governments, the authority is Local Government Code section 205.002, and the detailed rules in 13 Texas Administrative Code Chapter 7 apply to records with a retention period of at least 10 years.
For those longer-lived local records, the FAQ lists the conditions, including technical documentation, a security program, storage media kept in the right conditions and recopied on schedule, scanning that “conforms to industry standards and is done at the right resolution,” and “a visual quality control check” on at least 10 percent of documents. It also recommends running the conversion past auditors or other agencies that rely on the records, and gives “a soft recommendation of at least 6 months before shredding the paper copies.” The FAQ dates from 2020, so check the current Bulletin B before relying on its section numbers.
Washington
The Washington State Archives advice sheet, issued May 2024 and originally issued in September 2020, answers “YES” if the agency follows three steps. First, determine whether the records are “Archival” or “Non-Archival,” a designation shown on the retention schedules. Second, scan them according to the state’s requirements for destroying paper records after imaging, using the formats recommended for long-term records if they are archival. Third, for non-archival records, “destroy the paper records after verification of successful conversion”; for archival records, “contact Washington State Archives for an appraisal,” after which the paper is either selected for preservation at the State Archives or the agency is allowed to destroy it.
North Carolina
The State Archives of North Carolina’s imaging records page requires any agency that images records or keeps electronic records with retention periods of ten or more years “to create and sign an Electronic Records and Imaging Policy.” Local governments use a “Request for Destruction of Original Records Duplicated by Electronic Means” to ask approval to dispose of scanned paper, and that form “does not apply to… records with a permanent retention.” State agencies need their Chief Records Officer to approve an Authorization to Destroy Paper Records.
Permanent records go further. Offices must create a preservation duplicate under G.S. 132-8.2, and “it is the Department’s policy that preservation duplicates should be either a paper or microfilm copy of the original records.” In North Carolina, scanning alone does not replace a permanent paper record. The State Archives also offers a fee-based service for “converting digital records to archival microfilm for low-cost, long-term storage and access,” for both imaged and born-digital records.
Oregon
The Oregon State Archives’ Digitization Guidance, version 1, February 2026, describes itself as guidance, with the requirements in Oregon Administrative Rule 166-017-0035. It divides records by retention. If retention is less than 100 years, records “may be stored exclusively in a digital space once the scans have been reviewed for quality and completeness,” and the paper may be disposed of. If retention is expected to be 100 years or more, digital-only storage is allowed only if the storage environment meets OAR 166-017 and the State Archives’ Electronic Recordkeeping Requirements, in the file formats listed in OAR 166-017-0045(4).
The guidance also gives minimum scanning resolutions from the rule: 200 dpi for documents in ten-point type or larger with no signatures, 240 dpi grayscale for cancelled checks, and 300 dpi for smaller type, signatures, drawings, maps and line art.
Federal agencies
Federal agencies follow 36 CFR Part 1236 Subpart E, published at 88 FR 28417 on May 4, 2023, for digitizing permanent paper records and photographic prints. It does not cover negatives, transparencies, film or other transmissive materials. After a project, separate staff must validate the results; “once validated, the digitized records are permanent records,” and the agency then disposes of the source records under its schedule or a General Records Schedule, unless it has reasons to keep them.
GRS 4.5, last updated in Transmittal No. 37 (October 2026), is that general schedule. Item 010 allows destruction of source records “after validating the digitization process meets NARA’s digitization standards,” but excludes source records created before January 1, 1950 that are scheduled as permanent or unscheduled, and “source records that have intrinsic value in the original medium that would be lost if the content were converted to another medium.”
Two details matter for mixed series. Photographic prints within a textual series are covered and must meet the rule’s image standards, but negatives, slides and film are not, and GRS 4.5 tells agencies to use agency-specific schedules for media types the regulation does not cover. A series with a few negatives tucked into its folders therefore cannot be cleared under the general schedule as a whole.
The rule’s quality assurance steps are also a useful model for any office hiring a vendor. Agencies must quantify scanner or camera performance “before selecting the equipment by scanning a reference target and measuring the results with analytical software,” evaluate “internal or external vendor imaging systems” against the parameters, monitor performance during the work, and verify that the files meet the project’s specifications.
Legal permission is not the only legal question
A state rule that allows destruction after scanning does not override other obligations: litigation holds, audits, rights and benefits records, and agencies that rely on your originals. Check these before any paper leaves the building.
What the federal rule lists
The federal regulation is unusually specific about this. It says it “does not address other business needs or legal constraints that may make it necessary for an agency to retain source records for a period of time after digitizing,” and names the usual reasons: “rights and interests, appeal rights, benefits, national security, litigation holds, or other similar reasons.” GRS 4.5 repeats the warning and adds an instruction: “Consult with legal counsel before disposal.”
What the states add
Texas recommends running any conversion past “affected parties, like the auditors, or the federal or state agency to which the document is being submitted,” noting that its agency “is not the only government agency tasked with setting rules that affect records management.” North Carolina’s vendor checklist includes a “mechanism for avoiding spoliation of evidence” and a way to produce documents “due to litigation, audit, or public records request.” Colorado’s statute allows any state agency to impose “additional requirements for the retention of a record subject to the agency’s jurisdiction.”
Retention does not change
Scanning does not shorten or extend retention. Colorado’s FAQ says electronic records “are governed by the same accessibility and retention requirements as paper records,” and Texas says a digitized record “must be accessible and maintained for the full life-cycle of the record and minimum retention period, which can be forever in the case of permanent records.” If the schedule says a series is permanent, the digital copy you keep instead of the paper is now permanent too, with everything that implies for storage.
Which originals to keep anyway
Keep originals that have intrinsic value, meaning value in the physical object that a copy cannot carry. Permanent records with signatures, seals, bindings, early dates or questionable authenticity are the usual candidates, whatever the law would allow.
What intrinsic value means
The Society of American Archivists’ dictionary defines intrinsic value as “the usefulness or significance of a record derived from its physical or associational qualities, inherent in its original form and generally independent of its content, that are integral to its material nature and would be lost in reproduction.” It quotes the National Archives’ list of qualities that give a record intrinsic value:
| NARA quality (1999, as quoted by SAA) | What it can look like in a county or city vault |
|---|---|
| Physical form worth study as an example of the form | An early bound minute book, a hand-colored plat |
| Aesthetic or artistic quality | Engrossed resolutions, illustrated maps |
| Unique or curious physical features | Wax seals, ribbons, embossed stamps |
| Age that gives a quality of uniqueness | The earliest records of the jurisdiction |
| Value for use in exhibits | Founding documents shown at anniversaries |
| Questionable authenticity, date or author that physical examination can settle | Disputed deeds, altered entries, signatures |
| Association with historically significant people, places or events | Records of a disaster, a landmark case, a notable official |
| Documentation of the establishment or legal basis of the institution | Incorporation papers, charters, first ordinances |
| Documentation of high-level policy with broad effect | Records of decisions that shaped the jurisdiction |
The right-hand column gives illustrations, not rules; the qualities themselves come from the NARA list.
Signs that the paper itself is evidence
The sixth quality deserves attention in local government. If a record’s authenticity, date or authorship could ever be disputed, the paper, ink, seal and binding may be the only way to settle it. A scan shows what the page says; it rarely proves when or how it was made. The SAA dictionary also quotes Mary Lynn Ritzenthaler’s point that records with intrinsic value “that receive high use may be ideal candidates for copying or reformatting to preserve their informational content and protect the originals from excess handling,” which is the best reason to scan them: so the original can rest.
Ask the archives
Washington builds this judgment into its process, with an appraisal by the State Archives before archival records are destroyed. The federal GRS tells agencies to “consult your NARA appraiser” about possible intrinsic value. Even where your state does not require it, your state archives is the natural place to ask whether an old series should go to them rather than to the shredder.
Validate the scans before anything is destroyed
Before disposal, confirm that every page was scanned, that the images are legible and accurate, that the files and metadata are complete, and that someone other than the scanning staff has checked a sample. If the copy is going to become the record, it has to be proven complete first.
What the rules ask for
- Federal: visual inspection of “a random sample of a minimum of ten digital records or 10% of each batch,” or another statistically valid plan, on a calibrated monitor at 100 percent magnification. If 1 percent or more of examined records fail, the agency must find the cause, correct or redo the affected records and inspect again. Final validation is done by “separate staff… independent from the staff that performed the digitization QC inspections.”
- Texas: for local records kept 10 years or more, “a visual quality control check” on at least 10 percent of documents, plus the FAQ’s advice to check “a representative sample of documents to make sure that they are complete representations of the original.”
- Oregon: review each file in an initial batch “page by page,” then sample later batches, asking: “Can this digital version fulfill all of the same purposes as the original paper copy?”
- Washington: destroy non-archival paper only “after verification of successful conversion.”
What to check on every batch
The federal rule’s checklist is a good model even outside federal agencies. Validation confirms that all records in scope were digitized or documented as missing, that metadata is accurate and complete, that image attributes meet the specification, and that “all image files are legible and all physical characteristics necessary to understand and use the records have been captured.” The inspection list includes clipping, artifacts such as “dust, Newton’s rings, missing pixels,” and images that are “improperly cropped” or “flipped, inverted, or skewed.”
The federal rule also warns against judging quality by settings: an agency “cannot rely solely on equipment specifications, such as scanner ppi settings or camera sensor megapixels.” Our article on FADGI star ratings explains how quality is measured with targets instead. For the inspection itself, the image QC checklist covers completeness, image quality, files and batch sign-off.
How big a sample
For example, suppose a hypothetical batch of 3,000 scanned pages. Under the federal minimum of ten records or 10 percent, whichever is larger, the visual sample is 300 pages; Texas’s 10 percent figure for long-lived local records gives the same number. A statistical plan can justify a smaller or larger sample, depending on the defect rate you expect and how sure you need to be; the QC sample size calculator works that out. Whatever method you use, draw the sample at random from the whole batch, record the method, and keep the results with the destruction record.
Count pages, not boxes
One easy way for a scan to fail as a replacement is a missing page: a two-sided form scanned on one side, a folded attachment, a page stuck to the next. Reconcile counts at the item or page level against an inventory made before scanning. The federal rule makes the inventory a requirement before a project starts, identifying “whether the records are complete, if there are any gaps in coverage or missing records.” The same inventory notes “the disposition schedule under which the records fall, the date range when the records were created, any access or use restrictions that apply to the records, and the records’ storage location,” which is exactly what a destruction record later needs.
Keeping the digital copy for the full retention period
Once paper is gone, the scan is the record, and it must stay readable, unaltered and findable for the whole retention period, which for permanent records means indefinitely. Plan storage, fixity checks and migration before disposal, not after.
What the states require
Colorado’s statute requires that the electronic record “remains accessible for later reference.” Texas’s state agency rules require records to “remain readily retrievable and readable for as long as they are maintained,” by migration or by keeping the software and hardware needed. North Carolina’s guidance for agencies working with vendors names concrete intervals: data audited “at least annually,” media refreshed “at least every 3-5 years,” and checksum validation “at least at every migration.” Oregon makes agencies responsible for accessibility “for the entire duration of their retention period” under OAR 166-017.
Fixity and formats
The federal rule allows agencies to generate SHA-256 checksums for each image file once records are no longer in active use, and to use them “to monitor the digitized records for corruption or alteration.” For a local office, the same practice turns “we think the file has not changed” into evidence. Our article on the NDSA Levels of Digital Preservation for small archives sets out the first steps: copies in separate places, checksums, and knowing what file formats you hold.
Where the files live
Scans saved to a shared drive with no plan become, in Oregon’s words, “temporary” storage spaces that turn into “unintended ‘permanent’ storage spaces.” Before the first page is destroyed, the receiving system should be chosen, its folder structure and naming set, and its export path known, so the records can move when the system is replaced.
Searchable text is useful, not required
Text recognition makes scanned records searchable, which is often the point of scanning them. The federal rule “does not require that optical character recognition (OCR) be performed during digitization,” though it does not prevent it. Oregon notes that recognized text on poor-quality originals “may only be somewhat reliable.” Treat recognized text as a finding aid that sits beside the image, and keep the image as the record.
Questions to settle with a vendor or hosted system
North Carolina’s list of considerations for agencies contracting with scanning vendors is a practical checklist for anyone whose records will live in someone else’s system. Among its points:
- a plan for converting files to new formats, and annual audits of accessibility;
- media refresh and checksum validation intervals;
- system documentation that says which hardware and software the vendor provides;
- a mechanism for producing documents for litigation, audits or public records requests;
- any proprietary software needed to read the records;
- planned and unplanned downtime;
- a procedure for exporting records, “including images as well as metadata,” at the end of the contract or if the vendor stops operating.
If paper is going to be destroyed, the export clause is the one to read twice: the files may become the only copy of the record.
Write a scanning policy before you scan
A written scanning policy records what will be scanned, to what standard, where the files go, how they are checked and what happens to the paper. Colorado recommends one; North Carolina requires one for longer-lived records.
Colorado’s five topics
The Colorado State Archives recommends creating a scanning policy before any project and lists five topics it should cover: records retention requirements, technical scanning requirements, storage location and access, filing and organization, and preservation and disposition. That list is a sound outline in any state.
Other states build the policy into the process. North Carolina’s Electronic Records and Imaging Policy is “designed to be used as a self-evaluation tool” and replaced the former Self-Warranty Form; the State Archives publishes sample policies for local and state agencies. Washington’s advice sheet points agencies to the state’s requirements for destroying paper after imaging and asks that archival records use “the formats recommended for long-term records.”
What to put under each topic
- Retention requirements. The series covered, their schedule citations, and whether any are permanent or archival.
- Technical requirements. Resolution, color mode, file format, compression and how quality is measured. Oregon’s minimum dpi figures and the federal image parameters are useful references.
- Storage and access. The system that holds the files, who can see them, how public records requests are answered and how the files leave at the end of a contract. North Carolina lists a “procedure for exporting records (including images as well as metadata)” among the points to settle with vendors.
- Filing and organization. Folder structure, naming and the metadata captured with each file.
- Preservation and disposition. Checksums, backups and migration; the validation required before any destruction; who approves destruction; how originals with intrinsic value are identified and kept; and how destruction is documented.
Document the destruction itself
Record what was destroyed, under which authority, after which validation, on what date and by whom. North Carolina’s destruction request and Washington’s appraisal step produce that record by design; elsewhere, keep it yourself alongside the scanning project’s documentation.
A worked example: one county, three series
The example below applies the questions above to three series in one fictional county office. It deliberately uses no real retention periods.
Example (fictional). The Aster County clerk wants to free vault space and plans to scan three series. The county uses the State Archives’ schedules, and the clerk consults the State Archives and the county attorney before deciding anything.
- Commissioners’ proceedings, 1893 to 1896, one bound volume. The schedule lists the series as permanent. The volume is the county’s earliest record of its own decisions, signed by the board and the clerk, and it records the vote not to rebuild the Wren Gulch footbridge. It meets several intrinsic value qualities: age, association with the county’s founding years and documentation of its legal acts. Decision: scan for access and keep the volume, which can now rest in the vault while staff and residents use the images.
- Road petitions, 1950s, loose signed petitions in folders. Permanent on the schedule, often consulted when road ownership is questioned. The clerk notes that signatures on these petitions could one day be evidence. Decision: scan, validate and keep the originals, because the paper may matter in a dispute.
- A modern administrative series the schedule lists as non-permanent, with no legal hold and no unusual features. Decision: scan to the county’s written specification, validate by page count and a 10 percent visual check by a second staff member, store the files in the county’s records system with checksums, wait a set period after validation, then destroy the paper under the schedule and record the destruction.
Only the third series ends in destruction, and it is the one with the least intrinsic value and the shortest life. The vault space the clerk wanted comes mostly from that series, while the two older series become easier to use without being lost.
The pattern generalizes. Destruction after scanning works best for high-volume, non-permanent series with ordinary paper; permanent series with signatures, seals and age are better scanned for access and kept. Our page on local government records describes how such series are captured while originals stay in order.
What to do next
Start with the schedule, not the scanner. Identify which series are permanent or archival, which are not, and which have qualities worth keeping, then read your state archives’ current guidance before writing a scanning policy.
Checklist before any paper is destroyed
- Confirm the legal basis in your state’s statute and your state archives’ current guidance, and get any approval your state requires.
- Check the schedule for each series: permanent, archival or non-permanent, and the retention that applies.
- Check for holds and dependencies: litigation, audits, open public records requests, and other agencies that rely on the originals.
- Assess intrinsic value using the nine qualities above, and ask your state archives about old or unusual series.
- Write the scanning policy, covering at least Colorado’s five topics.
- Inventory before scanning, so completeness can be proved.
- Validate with page counts and a visual sample checked by someone other than the scanning staff.
- Secure the digital records with checksums, backups and a migration plan for the full retention period.
- Document the destruction: what, under which authority, when and by whom.
Mistakes that are hard to undo
- Scanning before clearing out eligible records, then paying to scan paper that could have been destroyed under the schedule.
- Relying on another state’s FAQ. The conditions differ, and a permission in Texas or Oregon says nothing about your state.
- Destroying permanent originals without checking the extra conditions, such as an appraisal, a microfilm or paper duplicate, or storage requirements.
- Treating scanner settings as proof of quality instead of inspecting the images.
- Skipping the page count, so a missing page is discovered only when someone needs it.
- Keeping scans on a shared drive with no plan for checksums, backups or migration.
- Destroying records under a hold because nobody checked with counsel.
Getting help with the scanning
If you scan through a vendor, write the image standard, the validation method and the return of originals into the contract. Our document scanning service returns originals in their original order and does not advise on disposition, which stays with your records officer, your schedules and your state archives. How originals are handled and returned while they are out of the vault is described on our collection care page.
This article is not legal advice. Rules change, and the sources above were read in November 2026; confirm the current requirements with your state archives and counsel before destroying any record.