Plan a pilot box
Menu

Image quality control checklist for digitization

Seventeen checks for every batch of images, from page counts and focus to checksums and sign-off, so problems are caught while the originals are still on the table.

Checklist

Tick items as you confirm them. Ticks stay on this page only; download the list when you are done.

Completeness
Image quality
Files
Recording

0 of 17 items confirmed

A missing page is cheap to fix while the volume is still open on the copy stand and expensive to fix after it has gone back to the shelf. Quality control is the step that finds it in time. This checklist covers what to check in each batch of images, whether the batch came from your own volunteers or from a vendor, and how to record what you found.

Use it on every batch, not only at the end of the project. Problems tend to repeat: one badly set light produces glare on a whole day’s work.

Completeness

  • Counts match the inventory. The number of images should equal the pages or items listed, plus the backs, envelopes and covers your capture policy includes.
  • Pages in order, including blank pages if your policy says to capture them. A blank page captured on purpose proves nothing was skipped.
  • Fronts and backs wherever the back carries writing, stamps or a studio imprint.
  • File names follow the naming scheme with no gaps or duplicates. A jump from 0002 to 0004 is usually a missing page. The file naming builder explains the pattern.

Image quality

  • Whole original in frame, with a small margin on every side. Nothing cropped, including the edges of oversize sheets.
  • In focus everywhere, including the gutter of bound volumes, where pages curve toward the spine.
  • No glare, reflections or hotspots, which hide pencil and faint ink and are common on glossy prints and photographs under glass.
  • No fingers, weights or clips over content.
  • Targets within tolerance. A color target and gray scale captured with the batch and measured against the agreed tolerances. FADGI’s guidelines are meant to be used with conformance evaluation targets and software, and a FADGI star rating is determined by meeting its evaluation parameters through image analysis, not by resolution alone.
  • Resolution and bit depth match the written specification. The scanning resolution calculator shows what pixel dimensions to expect.

Files

  • Masters open without error and are in the agreed format, usually TIFF.
  • Embedded metadata is present: resolution, color profile and identifier.
  • Access copies were made from the approved masters, not from an earlier or rejected capture.
  • Checksums were generated and stored with the batch, so any later change to a file can be detected.

Recording

  • Log every defect with the file name and the action taken.
  • Replace recaptured images, do not add them beside the old ones. Two versions of page 12 will confuse everyone downstream.
  • Sign off the batch with the sample size and the defect rate found.

How much to check

Check every image for completeness and file names; software can do most of that. Look at a random sample for image quality, and measure targets on a sample too. The QC sample size calculator works out how many images to look at: in its example, a lot of 2,000 images at 95 percent confidence, a 5-point margin of error and an expected defect rate of 5 percent needs a sample of 71 images. If you have no idea what the defect rate is, it suggests 323. Draw the sample at random from the whole batch, not from the first box.

Example (fictional). The Aster County Historical Society reviews the pilot box images of the Okerlund family papers and the Wren Gulch Mercantile day book.

  • Counts. The day book has 212 pages, so the batch should hold 212 page images plus the covers the policy includes. The 18 Halvorsen Studio cabinet cards have pencil notes on their backs, so they need 36 images, front and back.
  • Gutters. The day book opens to only about 110 degrees, so the reviewer checks focus close to the spine on every sampled spread.
  • A defect. achs_c003_b03_f012_i004_0002_m.tif, the second page of a folded letter, shows glare along the fold. The log records the file name, “glare on fold, recaptured”, and the new image replaces the old one under the same name.
  • Sign-off. The batch is signed off with the sample size and the defect rate, and both go into the pilot box report.

Using the checklist in a project

Agree the checks and the tolerances in writing before capture, so the vendor and the reviewer measure the same things. Print the list for the reviewer, or tick it here and download the CSV to file with each batch.

Our document scanning and photo and negative scanning services run these checks on every batch and capture to the level agreed in writing. The Reading Room’s capture and imaging section covers standards and targets in more depth, and a pilot box shows you real QC results on your own material.

Send one box first.

A pilot box shows you the images, the recognized text and the catalog records before you commit a whole collection. Tell us what is in the box and what you want people to find.

See QC results from a pilot box

Studio and contacts

24 South Weber Street, Suite 225
Colorado Springs, CO 80903
(719) 244-8450sales@dastok.com