Consult the tribal nations connected to the material before anything is imaged, not only before it is published, and let them decide what may be captured, who may handle and see it, and how it is described. If your institution receives federal funds and holds Native American human remains or cultural items, NAGPRA’s regulations (in effect since January 12, 2024) require free, prior and informed consent before allowing exhibition of, access to or research on them, and they define research to include “any study, analysis, examination, or other means of acquiring or preserving information.” For archival photographs, recordings and documents, the Protocols for Native American Archival Materials, endorsed by the Society of American Archivists in 2018, set the professional expectation of consultation and concurrence.
This article is not legal advice. It reads the regulation, the Protocols and the Local Contexts tools as published, and turns them into steps an archive, museum or historical society can take before capture. It does not speak for any tribal nation. Each nation decides its own protocols, and the right answer for a given photograph, song or object comes from the people it belongs to, not from a guide like this one.
A note on our position. Dastok digitizes collections, so we are among the people this article asks you to instruct and constrain. We do not decide what is sensitive, choose labels or interpret any community’s protocols.
Two kinds of material, two kinds of obligation
Native American materials in a non-tribal collection usually fall into two groups, and the rules differ for each. Human remains and cultural items held by an institution that receives federal funds are covered by NAGPRA’s regulations. Archival materials, such as photographs, sound recordings, field notes and documents, are generally not, but they are the main subject of the Protocols and of most community concerns about digitization.
The Department of the Interior drew that line itself. When it issued the revised regulations, commenters asked it to widen the definitions of human remains and cultural items to include documents, photographs, 3-D scans and digital data. The final rule (88 FR 86452, December 13, 2023) answered that it “cannot expand the definition to include intellectual property, digital files, other documents, or records as that would be inconsistent with the Act.” It noted instead that lineal descendants, Indian Tribes and Native Hawaiian organizations may request “records, catalogues, relevant studies, or other pertinent data,” and advised them to make requests “as broad as possible to ensure all information about cultural items, including digital data, is provided.”
| Material | Main framework | What it asks before digitization |
|---|---|---|
| Human remains, funerary objects, sacred objects, objects of cultural patrimony, at an institution that receives federal funds | NAGPRA regulations, 43 CFR part 10 | Consultation on handling; free, prior and informed consent before exhibition, access or research |
| Photographs, films and recordings of ceremonies, burials, sacred places or people | Protocols for Native American Archival Materials; donor agreements; privacy | Consultation and concurrence; respect for restrictions the community requests |
| Field notes, site records, maps of sacred or village sites, genealogical data | Protocols; for NAGPRA-related records, institutional policy built with consulting nations | Sensitivity review with the community; redaction or closure where asked |
| Records associated with repatriated items | No defined NAGPRA category; good practice per recent guidance | Discuss their care, return or closure during consultation |
The two groups often sit in the same box. An archaeological collection can include objects subject to NAGPRA alongside photographs of interments and site forms, and a donated album can hold both portraits and a small object found with it. Sort the material before capture, because the obligations attach at different moments.
What NAGPRA’s duty of care requires before imaging
If your institution is a “museum” under NAGPRA and holds human remains or cultural items, you must obtain free, prior and informed consent before allowing research on them, and the regulation’s definition of research is broad enough that imaging should be treated as included. That conclusion rests on the regulation’s own words, set out below, and on the Department’s explanation of them.
Who the duty applies to
The regulation’s definitions in 43 CFR 10.2 are wider than many small institutions expect:
- Museum “means any institution or State or local government agency (including any institution of higher learning) that has possession or control of human remains or cultural items and receives Federal funds.”
- Receives Federal funds covers any grant, cooperative agreement, loan, contract or use of federal facilities received after November 16, 1990, and “includes Federal financial assistance provided for any purpose that is received by a larger entity of which the institution or agency is a part.” A county museum inside a county government that receives federal money for any purpose is covered.
- Cultural items means “a funerary object, sacred object, or object of cultural patrimony according to the Native American traditional knowledge of a lineal descendant, Indian Tribe, or Native Hawaiian organization.” Whether an object is a cultural item is not the institution’s call alone.
- Possession or control means enough interest to “independently direct, manage, oversee, or restrict the use” of an item. Custody is an obligation to care for an item without that interest, as with most loans. The duty of care covers items in an institution’s custody as well as its possession or control.
The three requirements
43 CFR 10.1(d) requires a museum or federal agency “to care for, safeguard, and preserve any human remains or cultural items in its custody or in its possession or control.” It must:
- “Consult with lineal descendants, Indian Tribes, or Native Hawaiian organizations on the appropriate storage, treatment, or handling of human remains or cultural items;”
- “Make a reasonable and good-faith effort to incorporate and accommodate the Native American traditional knowledge” of those parties in storage, treatment or handling; and
- “Obtain free, prior, and informed consent from lineal descendants, Indian Tribes, or Native Hawaiian organizations prior to allowing any exhibition of, access to, or research on human remains or cultural items.”
The same paragraph defines research: it “includes, but is not limited to, any study, analysis, examination, or other means of acquiring or preserving information about human remains or cultural items.” It adds that “research of any kind on human remains or cultural items is not required by the Act or these regulations.”
Why imaging falls inside that definition
The regulation does not mention photography, scanning or 3-D capture by name. The Department’s explanation in the final rule says research “includes any activity to generate new or additional information beyond the information that is already available,” and gives as examples “physical inspection or review of collections” and “rehousing of collections.” A new photograph or scan of an object generates new information and preserves it. Reading those words plainly, imaging a cultural item is research under the rule, and so is giving a vendor or volunteer access to the item to image it.
The Department also explained what happens when no consulting party has yet been identified: “the museum or Federal agency must not allow any exhibition of, access to, or research on human remains or cultural items.” Its stated reason for the consent requirement is that institutions must obtain consent “before conducting activities that might physically or spiritually harm human remains or cultural items.” For a digitization project, the practical result is simple. Take NAGPRA-covered items out of the capture plan until consent has been given, and do not treat older photographs of them as permission to make new ones.
What to record
The final rule says that when consultation does not reach “consensus, agreement, or mutually agreeable alternatives, the consultation record must describe the concurrence, disagreement, or nonresponse of the consulting parties.” Keep that record for any decision about imaging, and keep it with the collection file, not only in someone’s email.
Questions about whether NAGPRA applies to a particular item belong with your counsel, the consulting parties and the National NAGPRA Program, not with a digitization plan.
What the Protocols ask of archives and libraries
The Protocols for Native American Archival Materials are the main professional guide for the archival side: photographs, recordings, manuscripts and records. They are not law, but the Society of American Archivists’ Council endorsed them as an external standard on August 13, 2018.
Where they come from
According to the Protocols themselves, nineteen Native American and non-Native archivists, librarians, museum curators, historians and anthropologists met at Northern Arizona University’s Cline Library in April 2006, including representatives of fifteen Native American, First Nation and Aboriginal communities. The group, the First Archivist Circle, wrote the Protocols as “a work in progress.” The SAA Council’s 2018 statement records that it had declined to endorse them in 2008 and 2012, and says, “We regret and apologize that SAA did not take action to endorse the Protocols sooner.”
The principles that bear on digitization
Several passages speak directly to capture and online access:
- Primary rights. “Libraries and archives must recognize that Native American communities have primary rights for all culturally sensitive materials that are culturally affiliated with them. These rights apply to issues of collection, preservation, access, and use of or restrictions to these materials.”
- Online reach. Institutions should “consider the potential impact of worldwide digital access to resources once only available onsite at the collecting institution,” and ask whether the information will “be presented with sufficient context.”
- Not every record should be kept forever. “At the request of a Native American community, avoid artificially prolonging the life cycle of sensitive documentary material.” The Protocols give examples such as “a photograph of a sacred ceremony, or object, or culturally sensitive documentation of a burial.”
- Consultation over time. The Protocols say that “in most instances it will take years for institutions and staff to develop essential trust relationships with a community,” and that weeks or months may be needed to work through a specific question.
- When there is no reply. An institution “may proceed with providing access to and use of material as it deems appropriate, but only if a community fails to respond to a good-faith effort to request consultation.”
The Protocols also record a concrete precedent: in 1991, the Cline Library and the Hopi Tribe agreed that “sensitive ceremonial images would not be reproduced (or digitized for Internet access) without written permission from the Hopi Cultural Preservation Office,” while on-site access continued. That example shows a common outcome: not a refusal to keep material, but a decision about which copies exist and where they can be seen.
Which materials to flag before capture
Flag material for consultation before it goes anywhere near a scanner, using the categories the Protocols list and then the community’s own judgment. The Protocols stress that “each community will understand and use the term ‘culturally sensitive’ differently,” so a list made by the institution is a starting point for a conversation, not a decision.
The Protocols give these examples of archival material that may be culturally sensitive:
| Format | Examples the Protocols list |
|---|---|
| Still and moving images, graphic art | Human remains; religious or sacred objects; ceremonies of any kind; burials and funerals; archaeological objects, especially from burials; hospitals, churches, cemeteries, kivas and sacred places |
| Recordings and transcripts | Songs and chants; music; religious practice; healing and medicine; personal or family information; oral histories; community histories; “myths,” folklore |
| Cartographic materials | Sacred or religious sites or areas; village sites, territories and use areas |
| Records, documents and texts | Personal or family information; archaeological data; religious materials; ethnobotanical materials; genealogical data |
Two further groups deserve attention in a digitization inventory. First, records that came to the institution under a research agreement with a community: the Protocols ask institutions to “acquire copies of and respect agreements made between communities and researchers who donate their collections.” Second, descriptions that use “outdated, inaccurate, derogatory, or Eurocentric language,” which the Protocols say “impedes access.” Captions written by a photographer a century ago will be transcribed, indexed and searched once they are digitized, so they need review as much as the images do.
Example (fictional). While preparing a digitization batch, the Aster County Historical Society opens a photograph album donated in 1952. Most of it is family portraits from the Halvorsen Studio, but eleven cabinet cards carry a photographer’s captions describing a religious ceremony and a burial, and an envelope tucked in the back holds a small beaded pouch.
The society takes the album out of the batch. Because it is part of county government, which receives federal funds, it treats the pouch as a possible cultural item under NAGPRA and handles it no further until consulting parties are identified. It writes to the cultural preservation office of the tribal nation whose homeland the captions name, describing the album, the eleven cards and the pouch, and asking how the nation would like them handled, whether any may be imaged, and who should be involved. It records the date of its letter and every reply. The family portraits continue through the batch. The eleven cards and the pouch wait, for as long as the conversation takes.
Consult before capture, not before publishing
Consultation has to happen before images are made, because capture itself is the step that cannot easily be undone. Once a vendor has imaged an item, copies exist on a capture workstation, in a working folder, in backups and perhaps in a preservation package, and text recognition or AI-assisted description may already have extracted words from it.
The NAGPRA rule’s definition of research treats “preserving information” as research in its own right, and the Protocols ask institutions to avoid “artificially prolonging the life cycle” of some material at a community’s request. A plan that consults only at the publishing stage has already made the decision those texts reserve for the community.
A sequence for consultation
- Find who to ask. The Protocols advise contacting “the chair’s office of each tribe that is or may be culturally affiliated” and, as a courtesy, the community’s cultural center, library, archives or cultural preservation office. The Bureau of Indian Affairs’ Tribal Leaders Directory lists contacts for each federally recognized tribe; it counts 575 as of January 30, 2026. Some communities connected to a collection are not federally recognized, and the Protocols’ guidance on consultation is not limited to recognized nations.
- Describe what you hold. Send an honest description of the material: what it is, how many items, how it came to you, what you know and do not know. Ask before you promise anything.
- Ask the open questions. Whether anything may be imaged; who may handle it; whether capture must happen in a particular place or way; who may see the images; how it should be described; whether some material should be closed, copied to the community or returned.
- Give it time. Fit the digitization schedule to the consultation, not the other way around. Work on other material meanwhile.
- Write down what is agreed. The Protocols recommend documenting agreements “through formal Memoranda of Agreement and/or other contracts” and honoring them. Note nonresponse and disagreement as well as agreement.
- Return to it. Agreements age, staff change and communities revisit decisions. Domeischel, Lofaro and Hebert suggest reviewing a digitization policy on a set schedule and recommend including consultation each time.
More than one community, more than one voice
Collections often relate to several communities, and the Protocols anticipate it. They ask institutions to “ensure equitable treatment in negotiations, whether a collection is culturally affiliated with one or more than one community,” and to offer comparable arrangements to all of them. They note that “consultation may involve more than one person,” and they ask communities, for their part, to tell institutions who will act as representatives: “a tribal archivist, historic preservation officer, cultural liaison, records manager, etc.” When the same photographs exist in several institutions, the Protocols ask that restrictions requested by a tribe be honored “in the same manner” everywhere, so check whether your copies duplicate material held elsewhere and what has been agreed there.
When the answer is “do not digitize”
Not digitizing is a complete and legitimate outcome. In their 2025 article on NAGPRA and digitization policy, Domeischel, Lofaro and Hebert write that digitization “may or may not be a viable step for your institution, particularly if your volume of records is heavily weighted toward those deemed sensitive by consulting Tribal Nations or other descendant communities.” They ask institutions to record the decision either way, so staff and visitors know what will and will not be done.
Plan access in more than two settings
Most collection systems offer two settings, public and private, and culturally sensitive material usually needs more. Agree the levels with the communities concerned before capture, because the level decides whether an item is imaged at all, at what quality and where the files may live.
Domeischel, Lofaro and Hebert recommend “a four-level system for categorization,” which they describe for NAGPRA-related records. Their levels, condensed:
| Level | Their description | What it means for digitization |
|---|---|---|
| I. Closed or sealed | Records a Tribal Nation has asked to be closed to all but its members, such as the private details of a religious ceremony | “These records will not be digitized.” |
| II. Highly sensitive | Not to be shared “without the informed consent of connected or affected communities,” such as photographs of interments or human remains and archaeological site data | Image only with consent and under agreed protocols |
| III. Possibly sensitive | Records not yet identified as sensitive or not, or not yet consulted on | Review each access request and consult before release |
| IV. Nonsensitive at this time | Records already reviewed for sensitivity by connected nations | May be made available as agreed |
The words “at this time” in level IV matter. A category is a present judgment, and the article recommends that institutions consult with Tribal Nations on the categories themselves, the records in each, and the users appropriate to each level.
Controls that make levels real
Levels only work if the systems enforce them. Before capture, confirm what your collection software and website can do, and choose the controls with the community:
- No image at all, for material that will not be digitized, with a record that says so.
- On-site viewing only, the arrangement in the Hopi and Cline Library agreement the Protocols describe.
- Community-only access, through accounts or a separate system the community controls.
- Redaction, such as removing site locations from field notes, a measure Domeischel and colleagues name.
- Descriptive notices that tell users why material is restricted and whom to contact.
- No public metadata, where even a title or caption would disclose too much.
The CARE Principles for Indigenous Data Governance, published by Carroll and colleagues in 2020, frame these choices more broadly: Collective Benefit, Authority to Control, Responsibility and Ethics. Their “authority to control” principle states that “Indigenous Peoples must be the ones to determine data governance protocols.” Digital images and their metadata are data in that sense.
Carrying restrictions, Notices and Labels in the records
Every restriction agreed in consultation should travel with the files and records it governs, in fields that survive export, migration and harvest. A restriction kept only in a meeting note or a spreadsheet beside the collection is the first thing lost when the catalog moves to new software.
Local Contexts: Notices for institutions, Labels for communities
Local Contexts provides two sets of tools, and the difference between them matters. Its Notices “are tools for institutions and researchers to identify Indigenous collections and data and recognize Indigenous rights and interests.” There are three kinds: Engagement, Disclosure and Collections Care Notices. Institutions generate them in the Local Contexts Hub, and “the text for the Notices cannot be changed.”
The Traditional Knowledge Labels belong to communities. Local Contexts describes them as “an initiative for Indigenous communities and local organizations” that lets communities “express local and specific conditions for sharing,” including for “sacred and/or ceremonial material, material that has gender restrictions, seasonal conditions of use.” The Labels fall into Provenance, Protocol and Permission groups, and “each Label is meant to be customized by a community.”
The sequence follows from that design. An institution applies a Notice to mark that Indigenous interests exist; the community then, in Local Contexts’ words, may “choose how and when to add their Labels.” An institution should not choose or apply a TK Label on a community’s behalf.
Fields to carry
Whatever system you use, agree a small set of fields and fill them for every affected item:
- Access level, using the categories agreed in consultation;
- Restriction statement, in words the community has approved, with a contact;
- Notice or Label, with the Local Contexts identifier or link where one exists;
- Consultation reference, pointing to the agreement or consultation record;
- Review date, when the decision should next be revisited;
- Description status, recording whether titles and subjects were written or reviewed with the community.
Put the same information in the preservation package, not only in the public catalog. A file found on a backup drive in twenty years should still say what may be done with it.
Copyright status is not the whole answer
A rights review that stops at copyright will miss most of what matters here. Under the Cornell copyright term chart, a photograph first published in the United States before 1931 is in the public domain, but that settles only who may copy it under copyright law. The Protocols point out that “existing copyright legislation does not address issues of significance to Native American communities such as: community ownership of works and management of rights; community interests in public disclosure of religious or sensitive information,” and the protection of oral traditions and songs. Citing the Australian solicitor Terri Janke, they note that copyright “protects authors and publishers but not the interests of those whose culture is described or depicted.” For a historical photograph, the author is usually the photographer, not the people in the picture.
In practice, record copyright status and community conditions in separate fields. A standardized rights statement answers the legal question; the access level, restriction statement and any Notice or Label answer the other one. Neither should overwrite the other.
Context written with the community
The Protocols suggest several ways to correct or extend description without erasing the original record. At a community’s request, an institution can add a notice such as “The [tribal name] finds information in this work inaccurate or disrespectful. To learn more contact,” followed by a contact. Derogatory words in original titles can be explained in a bracketed note or replaced with substitute language, and institutions are encouraged to “actively gather metadata” that reflects “the relationship between the creator or researcher and the community of origin.” In a digitized collection, keep the photographer’s original caption as a transcription, clearly labeled as such, and put the community’s description in its own field, so researchers can see both and know which is which.
Description, machine suggestions and reuse
Description needs the same care as access. The Protocols recommend working “with community representatives to revisit indexing terminology, Library of Congress Subject Headings,” and adding “cultural sensitivity statements” at a community’s request. Machine-suggested subjects and names drawn from older captions or general vocabularies can repeat exactly the terms the Protocols ask institutions to review, so treat them as drafts that a community-informed reviewer approves or replaces. Our article on labeling AI-generated metadata explains how to keep machine suggestions visibly separate until a person has checked them.
Agree in advance whether text recognition, AI-assisted description or any outside service may process the material at all. Some communities will not want recordings transcribed by software or images run through external models. Our AI policy lets clients opt out of any machine step for a collection or series, and it states that client files are not used to train third-party general models without written permission.
Handling, custody and the people who capture
Whoever images the material, staff, volunteers or a vendor, works under the institution’s obligations and the community’s agreed conditions. Put those conditions in writing before anyone opens the box.
A digitization contract or work order for this material should state:
- which items may be imaged, and which may not be handled at all;
- who may handle them, where the community has asked that only certain people do so;
- where capture happens, including on site if the community or the institution prefers that the material not travel;
- what capture is allowed: resolution, views, whether 3-D or multispectral imaging is permitted;
- that no copies are kept by the vendor after delivery, and how working files are deleted;
- that files are not passed to other services, including AI services, without agreement;
- how restrictions are recorded in the delivered metadata and files;
- who to call if something unexpected is found, such as an object tucked inside an album.
The Protocols also ask institutions to “refrain from attempting to perform specialized care, such as smudging, offering corn pollen, or a general blessing, for sacred or spiritual items,” because “rituals or ceremonies should only be conducted by religious or cultural practitioners,” and to accommodate those practitioners where possible. For a capture session that can mean scheduling around a visit, or adjusting the room and procedures when a practitioner is present.
Our collection care page describes custody, handling and transport in general terms, and our page for museums covers object imaging. Neither replaces the conditions a community sets for its own material.
Federal funding brings the duty with it
Grant-funded digitization is a common way for this material to reach a scanner, and federal grants carry NAGPRA with them. NEH’s 2026 Collections Stewardship notice, for example, reminds applicants that NAGPRA “applies to any organization that controls or possesses Native American human remains and associated funerary objects and that receives federal funding, even for a purpose unrelated to the Act.” If you are planning a funded project, settle consultation before the application, not after the award; our survey of digitization grants covers the current federal programs.
When digitization serves a community: copies, return and shared care
Digitization is not only a risk to manage. Communities often ask for copies of records about their own history, and a well-made digital copy can be the fastest way to answer. The question is who decides what the copy is for and who holds it.
The Protocols ask archives and libraries to “respond cooperatively to requests for copies of records for community use and retention,” noting that “resources held at a distance may become estranged from the people to whom they are most relevant.” They go further on originals. Materials collected on the basis of a trust relationship “can and should revert to community control upon request,” and originals “obtained through theft or deception” should be repatriated. Where cultural items are repatriated under federal law, the Protocols suggest that the institution “should also consider transferring primary physical ownership and all copyright or literary rights” for associated archival materials. They also anticipate co-custody: a community may ask an institution to keep records in trust until a tribal archive requests their return.
NAGPRA points the same way for records about cultural items. The Department’s explanation of the final rule says lineal descendants, Indian Tribes and Native Hawaiian organizations “have a right to request records, catalogues, relevant studies, or other pertinent data,” that institutions “are required to share that information,” and it advises requesters to ask for “all information about cultural items, including digital data.” Domeischel, Lofaro and Hebert add that, although the regulations do not address records left after repatriation, “it is good practice to include the topic of long-term care (or return) of the associated records” in consultation.
For a digitization plan, that suggests a few practical choices to offer, never to impose:
- Copies for the community first. Image material at the quality the community needs for its own archive, and deliver the files to it, before or instead of any public release.
- Files the community controls. Where a community wants images but not public access, the files can live in a system it manages, with the institution keeping only what is agreed.
- Return with documentation. When originals go home, the Protocols suggest institutions “request permission to hold copies,” for example to prove former ownership. Whether any copy stays is the community’s decision.
- No copy at all. Some material may be returned without being imaged, and the record should say so.
These options are not ours to choose between. They are a list of what a capable digitization team can do once the community has decided what it wants.
A checklist before any capture
Use this list before Native American materials enter a digitization batch. It does not replace consultation; it makes sure consultation happens first.
- Sort the material. Separate possible human remains and cultural items from archival material, and take both out of the capture plan until consultation is under way.
- Check NAGPRA status. Confirm with counsel whether your institution, or a body it belongs to, receives federal funds, and whether you hold items in custody or in possession or control.
- Identify connected communities. Use provenance records, captions, donor files and the Tribal Leaders Directory, and ask the communities themselves who should be involved.
- Write first, describe honestly. Share what you hold and ask open questions about imaging, handling, access, description and return.
- Wait for answers. Fit the schedule to the consultation. If there is no response, record your good-faith efforts before deciding anything, as the Protocols describe.
- Agree levels and controls. Decide which items are not imaged, which are seen only on site or only by the community, and which may be shared.
- Set up the fields. Access level, restriction statement, Notice or Label, consultation reference and review date, in the catalog and in the preservation package.
- Decide on machine processing. Agree whether text recognition or AI-assisted description may be used, and by whom.
- Brief everyone who handles the material. Give staff, volunteers and any vendor the written conditions before the box is opened.
- Schedule a review. Put the next consultation on the calendar.
If you are a tribal archive or a community organization planning your own digitization, our page on community and tribal archives describes how we work under a community’s rules: you decide what is captured, who sees it and how it is described. If you want to talk through a project, start with your protocols, before any material is chosen.